Main

May 9, 2008

City is urged to sell airport, DCU, cemetery

Source: By Mark Melady TELEGRAM & GAZETTE (MA), Thursday, May 8, 2008

The Research Bureau has again urged the city to unload some of its properties, including the airport, the DCU Center, Union Station and the Senior Center, and recommended other cost-saving measures such as outsourcing custodial services, ending paid police details at construction sites, further reducing employee health insurance costs, and limiting police and fire injured-on-duty compensation.

May 6, 2008

Harrisburg Mayor unveils ambitious parking proposal

Source: By Eric Veronikis, Central Penn Business Journal (PA), 5/5/2008

Harrisburg Mayor Stephen R. Reed this afternoon revealed a plan to lease 11 Harrisburg Parking Authority garages, its parking lots and approximately 900 metered parking spaces in the city to a private company, which would pay the authority a one-time up front sum of $215 million.

..... The plan hinges on City Council's approval and negotiations with AFSCME local 521 B, the union which represents authority parking garage employees. The new operator would employ existing garage employees at the same rate and might add more workers, Reed said.

...... HPP would sign a 75-year lease under the proposal. The authority would still own and operate parking on City Island, Reed said. It would own the garages HPP would operate under the lease. The authority could still develop new parking garages, Reed said. HPP is owned by New York-based North American Strategic Infrastructure Partners and Connecticut-based LAZ Parking.

....... State law requires leases of 30 years or more to be subjected to real estate transfer taxes, Reed said. This deal would deliver about $1.1 million in transfer taxes to the city and the Harrisburg School District, separately, he said.

May 2, 2008

Sluggish economy hinders turnpike-leasing plan

Source: By Paul Nussbaum, Philadelphia Inquirer (PA), Fri, May. 2, 2008

Turbulent financial markets have hampered prospective bidders for the Pennsylvania Turnpike, prompting the Rendell administration to extend the bidding period for several weeks.

The field of potential bidders for the turnpike has shrunk from 14 teams to about five, Roy Kienitz, deputy chief of staff to Rendell, said yesterday. So far, none has submitted a bid.

April 2, 2008

6 groups want to purchase Midway Airport

Source: BY FRAN SPIELMAN, Chicago Sun Times (IL), April 2, 2008


Six teams -- one including some of the same players who paid $1.82 billion to lease the Chicago Skyway -- will vie for the right to make Midway Airport the nation's first privately-run commercial airport.

....... Roughly $1.3 billion of the windfall will be used to pay off Midway Airport debt. Up to half of the net proceeds will be used to shore up under-funded city employee pension funds. The rest will be used to build libraries, parks, schools, museums, police and fire stations.

States scrambling to find funds to fix roads, bridges / Many explore infrastructure privatizing.

Source: By Donna Borak, Associated Press, April 2, 2008


Frozen credit markets, sky-high gasoline prices, and a rising federal budget deficit are hurting cash-strapped states as they confront increasing congestion on the nation's deteriorating roads and bridges.

States are desperate to tap every possible source of funding - tolls on leased roads, sharp increases in taxes on motor fuels, and partnering with the private sector - to finance the building and repairing of roads and bridges.

Experts see sharp increases in states partnering with the private sector for funding. Some analysts say highway funding may be the next "sweet spot" for institutional investors as the burst housing bubble leaves firms looking for ways to put their money to work.

....... There is, however, a big downside: The company that would lease the turnpike likely would implement "aggressive toll increases" for drivers, according to a recent House Democratic study.

March 31, 2008

Toll Road to hike most fees Tuesday

Source: By Bill Ruthhart, Indianapolis Star, March 31, 2008


Each of the 21 plazas on the Indiana Toll Road will offer electronic tolling starting Tuesday, but fees will be about double for commuters who do not use i-Zoom passes. The toll increases were scheduled as part of the June 2006 agreement by the state to lease the Northern Indiana highway to a private consortium for 75 years at a price tag of $3.8 billion.

Akron floating plan to lease sewer system

Source: Akron Beacon Journal (OH), Saturday, Mar 29, 2008

......... In his annual State of the City address on Feb. 7, Mayor Don Plusquellic proposed selling the city's sewer system to pay for scholarships for Akron's public high school graduates to the University of Akron or to trade schools.

....... The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, a union whose members could lose jobs under concession agreements, says pretty much the same thing. ''Investors will make their money from future users paying higher tolls and fees over the life of the agreements,'' the union said in January in an assessment of the Chicago and Indiana deals.

...... The local chapter of AFSCME, which represents Akron's sewer workers, has said it would fight Plusquellic's proposal, and other Akron residents have raised concerns.

March 25, 2008

Providence to look at sale of water system

Source: By Daniel Barbarisi, Providence Journal (RI), Tuesday, March 25, 2008

The city is considering selling the Providence Water Supply Board and the network of reservoirs and treatment plants it controls in order to pay down the huge debt in the city's pension system.

...... The money from a sale would be used to pay off the debt to the city's pension system, which is owed roughly $700 million.

March 17, 2008

Letting the Market Drive Transportation / Bush Officials Criticized for Privatization

Source: By Lyndsey Layton and Spencer S. Hsu, Washington Post, Monday, March 17, 2008

...... For Gribbin, Duvall and Transportation Secretary Mary Peters, the goal is not just to combat congestion but to upend the traditional way transportation projects are funded in this country. They believe that tolls paid by motorists, not tax dollars, should be used to construct and maintain roads. They and other political appointees have spent the latter part of President Bush's two terms laboring behind the scenes to shrink the federal role in road-building and public transportation.

They have also sought to turn highways into commodities that can be sold or leased to private firms and used by motorists for a price. In Duvall and Gribbin's view, unleashing the private sector and introducing market forces could lead to innovation and more choices for the public, much as the breakup of AT&T transformed telecommunications.

March 4, 2008

Rendell's plan to lease turnpike unwise, study says

Source: Paul Nussbaum, Philadelphia Inquirer (PA), Tue, Mar. 4, 2008


A study done for state House Democrats has concluded that it is unwise to lease the Pennsylvania Turnpike to a private operator, as Gov. Rendell hopes to do. Instead, the study supported the legislature's move to keep the Turnpike Commission, raise tolls on the turnpike, and introduce tolls on I-80. The study, by three experts from Pennsylvania State and Harvard Universities, is to be formally released today in Harrisburg.

February 28, 2008

Daniels boosts privatizing Gary airport

Source: BY KEITH BENMAN, Northwest Indiana Times (IN), Thursday, February 28, 2008 | 20 comment(s)

Gov. Mitch Daniels told a conservative Washington think tank on Monday that leasing Gary/Chicago International Airport to a private operator represents a "heck of an opportunity" for Gary.

January 28, 2008

Private Interest In Rail To Dulles

Source: By Amy Gardner, Washington Post (VA), Monday, January 28, 2008


Private equity investors are drawing up proposals to partner with Virginia for a rail line to Dulles International Airport as hope fades that the federal government will help fund the 23-mile Metrorail extension.

State officials said several equity groups have expressed interest in investing in a rail since Thursday, when U.S. transportation officials declared the project unfit for federal funding. The $5 billion project had been counting on a $900 million grant from the Federal Transit Administration.

Private purchase of the rail line or the Dulles Toll Road to fund the extension would attract strong opposition from those who believe such public infrastructure is far too valuable to hand over to for-profit corporations. But with the outlook for keeping the rail project alive bleak, regional business and political leaders who are adamant that the rail line must not die are increasingly of the mind that private partnership must be considered.

January 16, 2008

Turnpike privatization has negative impact

Source: UPI, Jan. 15, 2008 at 2:33 PM


A study suggests privatizing U.S. toll roads might result in significant diversions of truck traffic that could cause increased accidents and costs. Penn State University Assistant Professor Peter Swan and Michael Belzer of Wayne State University used federal and Ohio Turnpike data to conclude that if governments allow private toll road operators to maximize profits, higher tolls will divert trucks to local roads -- and that is important for economic and social reasons.

...... The study was presented Monday in Washington during the annual meeting of the Transportation Research Board.


Penn State news release: Toll road privatization may result in indirect impacts

January 11, 2008

State joins list of others tapping into lottery

Source: By Joseph Spector, Ithaca Journal (NY), January 11, 2007

Gov. Eliot Spitzer's announcement this week to explore a lease of the state lottery puts New York among a number of states looking to roll the dice on getting an infusion of cash to pay for services.

But from constitutionality questions to concerns about the social consequences of putting the gambling operations in private hands, no state has yet to adopt the potentially lucrative deals.

Lawmakers and gaming experts Thursday questioned whether New York would face the same issues as it explores either selling future lottery revenue in a lump sum or leasing it to a private entity for possibly up to 40 years.

December 19, 2007

Nevada study group pushing for private toll roads

Source: Landline Magazine, December 18, 2007


In hopes of tapping into public-private partnerships to build highways in Nevada, a special panel created by the governor has decided to call on state lawmakers to make it happen.

The study committee, created by Gov. Jim Gibbons, recommended asking the Nevada Legislature to authorize pursuing deals with private groups to build highways.

November 26, 2007

Leasing plan would hike Florida road tolls

Source: The Associated Press (FL), 11/26/2007

Faced with a $2.5 billion budget shortfall over the next two years, Florida officials are considering selling 50-year leases on Alligator Alley and other state toll roads and bridges in exchange for large sums of cash from private investors.

In a preliminary study, the Florida's Department of Transportation estimated a 50-year lease on Tampa's Sunshine Skyway Bridge could be worth $1.3 billion if investors were allowed to set tolls at ''market rates.'' Alligator Alley could bring in $1.3 billion as well, according to the estimates.

October 30, 2007

Building sell-off 'bad deal for Canadians'

Source: CUPE, October 29, 2007 02:27 PM

New research shows the Conservative government lowballed the price of federal buildings it recently sold as a P3 scheme.

The Informetrica analysis, commissioned by the Public Service Alliance of Canada, shows the undervaluing of the real estate assets means a $400 million windfall for Larco Investments, the corporation that bought the buildings.

October 26, 2007

Detroit seeks to sell off 92 parks

Source: BY ZACHARY GORCHOW, Detroit Free Press (MI), October 26, 2007

One-quarter of Detroit's 367 parks could be sold under a proposal designed to help the city shed dozens of its smallest and most worn-down parks in an effort to aid others and position the land for redevelopment.

........ The city already has sold other assets this year -- including Camp Brighton and Rogell Golf Course -- to ease budget problems. But money from selling the parks would be put back into the park system, either by acquiring land for new parks or by rehabilitating others, said Vincent Anwunah, general manager of the Recreation Department's planning, design and construction management division.

The city estimates it could get $8.1 million from selling the land, and $5.4 million per year from new tax revenue, while saving $540,000 annually by discontinuing maintenance at those parks.

October 22, 2007

Who Really Owns the Roads?

Source: By Barbara Kiviat, Time, Thursday, Oct. 18, 2007

....... For states and cities looking to upgrade or replace aging infrastructure, partnering with private players is the biggest idea to come along since the interstate highway system started ribboning the country with asphalt in the 1950s. The appeal: governments can stop worrying about roads, bridges and tunnels, and companies get lucrative leases that allow them to collect money from drivers for generations. The craze is being driven by investors who crave the steady cash flow of decades' worth of tolls. There are 71 projects worth $104 billion being considered for private development by state and local governments, according to the publication Public Works Financing. The proposals are feeding a new pack of investment funds from the likes of Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and the Carlyle Group--as well as controversy over how roads should be paid for.


....... At the core of the debate is a fundamental issue: Is building roads one of those things, like trade policy, that only the Federal Government should steer, or is there a better way?

Group pushes to privatize lottery / 4 GOP senators to file bill today

Source: By Andrea Estes, Boston Globe (MA), October 22, 2007


As Governor Deval Patrick's casino bill is being debated on Beacon Hill, a group of Republican lawmakers is pushing another way for the state to reap a large gambling windfall: privatizing the Massachusetts lottery.

........ Though several states have debated lottery privatization, none has approved it. California and Texas would probably be the first to close a deal, according to investment bankers and others who have pitched proposals around the country. The state would solicit proposals from bidders, who would have to pay $1 million to have their proposal considered, the bill says.

October 19, 2007

State takes first steps for tolls on I-80 / Pike Commission, PennDOT sign deal for 50-year lease

Source: By Joe Grata, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PA), Wednesday, October 17, 2007

State officials have accomplished the first two steps toward converting Interstate 80 into a toll road, starting with signing a 50-year lease agreement between the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission.

Some States Consider Leasing Their Lotteries

Source: NELSON D. SCHWARTZ and RON NIXON, New York Times, Sunday, October 14, 2007


.... Like shoppers at convenience stores who can't resist placing bets when lotto jackpots get big enough, government officials in at least a dozen states are considering lottery privatizations -- what would collectively amount to the biggest privatization of a government enterprise in American history.

Wall Street, positioned to play an important role in orchestrating these deals, is looking at some very big prizes itself. If privatization plans now being considered in four large states -- California, Illinois, Texas and Florida -- were to go through, Wall Street could conservatively reap a minimum of $250 million in fees alone.

October 12, 2007

The Road to Privatization: Implications of Public-Private Partnerships for Transportation Projects

Source: Maryland General Assembly, Department of Legislative Services (.pdf), Office of Policy Analysis


Beginning with the construction of the highway interstate network, highways and transit have typically been funded by federal and state aid derived from the motor fuel tax. However, given the national reluctance to increase the motor fuel tax coupled with more fuel efficient automobiles, motor fuel tax revenue growth has not kept pace with construction costs. In addition, there has been an increasing demand for transportation system preservation and new projects to meet the increasing demands of congestion. To address the needs of residents and the relative static growth in the motor fuel tax, a new national trend appears to be developing in financing transportation projects.

Specifically, a growing national interest is developing in partnering with the private sector to access cash and equity that might not otherwise be available for transportation projects. The relationship between the public and private sector is commonly known as a public-private partnership (P3). The partnership can take several forms, including the State leasing an existing revenue generating State asset to a private entity for operation in exchange for a lump sum payment. Alternatively, the private sector can construct a transportation infrastructure project, generally a toll road, for the right to collect future revenues.

....... In considering P3s and the role of private finance in transportation infrastructure, there are a number of issues for the State to consider, including the role of the legislature, the legal framework for such an agreement, and how the State should engage the private sector.

I-80 toll conversion speeds on

Source: By Joe Grata, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PA), Friday, October 12, 2007


Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission officials are to formally sign a landmark lease no later than Monday to convert Interstate 80 into a toll road.

The 50-year agreement is designed to create what they call a unique "public-public partnership" to generate a total of $116 billion.

September 28, 2007

Would Lottery Lease Be State's Winning Ticket?

Source: By JEROME R. STOCKFISCH The Tampa Tribune (FL), Sep 27, 2007

...... Now, the state lottery and a handful of toll roads and bridges are drawing the interest of private investors who are putting a price tag on those assets and want a piece of the action.

Facing a $1.1 billion hole in the state budget because of an economic slowdown, the state is listening.

This summer, major Wall Street firms approached Florida, as they have other states, with the prospect of leasing the state lottery.

September 27, 2007

Stewart handover awaits lease revision

Source: By Hank Gross, Daily Freeman (NY), 09/27/2007

NEW WINDSOR - The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey intends to take over the operation of Stewart International Airport on Nov. 1, but before that can be accomplished, a number of steps must be completed.

The state Transportation Department, the airport's owner, is in the process of revising the operating lease, which was written for National Express Corp. about six years ago. The remaining 93 years of that lease is being sold to the Port Authority.

......The Port Authority is paying $78.5 million for the remainder of the airport lease. National Express paid $35 million for it in 2001.

September 24, 2007

Private toll roads may be in state's future

Source: BY LARRY LEBOWITZ, Miami Herald (FL), Mon, Sep. 24, 2007

....... Florida is in another budgetary down cycle.

...... Faced with multibillion-dollar shortfalls, Gov. Charlie Crist is considering selling long-term leases on such valuable state assets as the Florida Lottery and toll roads. ''Everything is still on the table,'' said Pamela Griffis, a spokeswoman for Transportation Secretary Stephanie Kopelousos. ``Nothing is set in stone, but we're looking at everything.''

September 13, 2007

Lack of revenue puts pressure on county road department

Source: Misty Bell, The Messenger (AL), September 13, 2007

With gas prices rising (along with the prices for most everything else), the Pike County Road Department is feeling the pressure.

"The bottom line is that there's not enough revenue to maintain the county's roads and bridges at today's prices," Herb Huner, head of the county road department, said.


...... Gov. Bob Riley favors privatization over a new gas tax, Gipson said. Privatization would allow private investors to pay for roads and then charge a toll for their use.

August 31, 2007

TxDOT plan would convert some interstates to toll roads

Source: By POLLY ROSS HUGHES, Houston Chronicle (TX), August 31, 2007

The Texas Department of Transportation is pushing Congress to pass a federal law allowing the state to "buy back" parts of existing interstate highways and turn them into toll roads.

The 24-page plan, outlined in a "Forward Momentum" report that escaped widespread attention when published in February, drew prompt objections Thursday from state lawmakers and activists fighting the spread of privately run toll roads.

........ The report not only advocates turning stretches of interstate highways into toll roads, but it also suggests tax breaks for private company "investment" in such enterprises.

It seeks changes in federal law to allow the use of equity capital as a source of transportation funding. Along with that, it calls for altering the tax code to "exempt partnership distributions or corporate dividends related to ownership of (a) toll road from income taxation."

....... Anti-toll road activist Sal Castello, the Austin-based founder of the TexasTollParty.com, said he's frustrated by the "schemers and the scammers" who "never stop" divisive toll road proposals despite widespread opposition and fretted that a required referendum could be creatively worded to disguise the conversions.

Private equity sees gold mine in potholes

Source: By Jonathan Keehner, Reuters, Thu Aug 30, 2007 1:35PM EDT

Private equity firms suddenly short on big buyout targets are revisiting an elusive goal -- the privatization of infrastructure.

The crumbling network of roads, ports and bridges have previously intrigued private equity, but a political backlash derailed a wave of anticipated deals sparked by the Chicago Skyway lease for $2 billion in 2005.

Cash-strapped states might now reconsider their aversion, especially if private equity firms are willing to spend as enthusiastically for infrastructure assets as they were before a credit crunch made public markets unreceptive to them.

August 30, 2007

Editorial: Troubled toll road's sale is best of a bad situation

Source: The Denver Post Editorial Board, 8/29/2007 08:24:31 PM MDT

We're not overjoyed about the takeover of the Northwest Parkway by foreign investors. It's hard to cheer about the prospect of paying tolls for 99 years to travel the 9-mile link between Interstate 25 and the Boulder Turnpike - as the sale ensures will happen.

But the sale to Portuguese-based Brisa and CCR of Brazil was probably the best outcome available for the financially troubled toll road - a necessary link in the metro area's still incomplete beltway network.

August 27, 2007

Just say 'no' to privatization

Source: By Mark Capron, PUBLIC WORKS MAGAZINE, August 1, 2007

Keep roads in public hands by making it easier for transportation planners to deploy intelligent electronics technology.

Your editorial about transportation departments granting long-term toll road operating concessions to foreign firms like Australia's Macquarie Infrastructure Group (April 2007, "Leased to the highest bidder!") asks a good question: "If operating public infrastructure makes good business sense, why are we getting out of the business?"

We don't have to. The public sector can improve full-spectrum service--not just transit time, but safety, costs, air quality, aesthetics, noise, and the environment--by implementing "intelligent" vehicle technology that's available today.

August 1, 2007

Alabama governor stumping for tolls, privatization of roads

Source: Land Line Magazine, July 31, 2007

Gov. Bob Riley has a message for residents in Alabama who want better roads: consider tolls roads or public-private partnerships.

........ Former U.S. Transportation Secretary Norman Mineta recently shared that sentiment. Mineta visited the state this spring to stand by Riley and tout the benefits of tolls over more fuel taxes.

July 30, 2007

Privatization drive slowed by roadblocks

Source: Reuters, Mon Jul 30, 2007 11:22AM EDT

What Wall Street had thought would be a flood of infrastructure deals has turned out to be a trickle.

Last year bankers predicted cash-strapped state and city governments would sell or lease airports, toll roads and other public assets to investors with billions of dollars clamoring for stable, long-term returns.

Instead, public resistance against such sales has caused government officials in many states to hesitate, slowing deal traffic to a crawl.

July 27, 2007

Angry Rendell revives turnpike lease

Source: By Tom Barnes, Post-Gazette (PA), Thursday, July 26, 2007


Gov. Ed Rendell assailed two Republican congressmen for trying to block the state's plans to place tolls on Interstate 80, saying their actions leave him no choice but to revive his unpopular plan to lease the Pennsylvania Turnpike to a private operator.

July 23, 2007

Consortium to lease toll road for 99 years

Source: By Jeffrey Leib, Denver Post, 06/01/2007

A team of companies from Portugal and Brazil has agreed to lease the financially distressed Northwest Parkway toll road for 99 years in a deal valued at $603 million.

The transaction buys out the roughly $503 million in bond debt carried by the toll highway and includes an additional $60 million that the companies will contribute for the extension of the road to Colorado 128, near Rocky Mountain Metropolitan Airport (formerly Jefferson County Airport), said parkway executive director Steve Hogan.

July 18, 2007

Unloading Assets

Source: Christopher Swope, Governing, January 2007, Vol. 20 no. 4

Cities and states are privatizing major pieces of infrastructure. Are they getting a sweet deal or selling out?

July 17, 2007

Selling Public Assets Generates Fast Cash

Source: Ed Brock and Brian Sedlak, American City & County, Vol. 122 no. 4, April 1, 2007

By selling public assets, local and state governments are raising funds and paying down debts without increasing taxes. The strategy was first applied to toll roads, and now parking garages and state lotteries are up for sale or lease to private investors. Asset concessions are used to bridge budget gaps while increasing or maintaining revenue from unprofitable assets.

Public Asset Sales: Does the Public Benefit from State Lottery Sales?

Source: Jay Young, PA Times, Vol. 30 no. 3, March 2007
(subscription required)

After years of reduced federal support from Congress and the Bush Administration, state and local governments have recently been aggressively pursuing new sources of revenue to meet the service requirements of its citizens. Increasing taxes on income, real property, or even sales taxes are widely viewed as anti-business, anti-citizen and the equivalent to political suicide….

… Recently governments have begun to privatize assets to generate increased cash from either one time payments, a royalty like stream, or a combination of the two…

July 3, 2007

Gambling On The Future: Should California Privatize The State Lottery?

Source: California Budget Project, Budget Brief (.pdf), June 2007


In conjunction with his May Revision to the 2007-08 Proposed Budget, the Governor proposes to privatize the California lottery. The Governor suggests that the lottery could be leased on a long-term basis to a private contractor for a one-time payment of up to $37 billion.

1 Documents prepared by investment bankers suggest that the state could receive $13 billion to $18 billion from a long-term lease. In addition to promising that public education would receive, at a minimum, “the same dollar level of funding that it received in the highest year of lottery funding,” the Governor states that proceeds from the lease should be used to pay down the state’s debt.

2 The Governor’s proposal assumes that a private contractor could significantly increase lottery ticket sales. This Budget Brief examines whether the California lottery is, in fact, underperforming; whether privatization is necessary to increase lottery sales; and policy issues raised by the Governor’s proposal.

June 26, 2007

Missouri taps into the sale of student loans

Source:By Pamela M. Prah, Stateline.org, June 26, 2007


……. States leery of tax increases increasingly are looking at raising revenue by selling assets — from Indiana’s lease of its turnpike last year to California’s proposal to sell control of its state lottery — but Missouri’s bitter battle could serve as a cautionary tale.

...... Sujit CanagaRetna, a tax and budget expert at the Council of State Governments, predicts that despite the prospect of political fights, governors will continue to push leasing and privatization plans because states need the money for new projects and don’t want to raise taxes. “It’s definitely a trend that’s here to stay,” he said.

June 20, 2007

Teamsters rally against Pa. Turnpike privatization

Source: By Brad Bumsted, Pittsburgh Tribune Review (PA), Wednesday, June 20, 2007

In an effort to save 2,000 jobs at the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission, members of the Teamsters Union fanned out Tuesday at the Capitol to lobby against Gov. Ed Rendell's proposed lease of the turnpike to a private company.

June 12, 2007

Is time right to sell state stores? State senator pushes bill to privatize liquor sales

Source: By Steve Twedt, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PA), Tuesday, June 12, 2007

A Montgomery County state senator wants Pennsylvania to get out of the retail wine and liquor business -- and one of his proposals involves selling a 51 percent stake in the state store system to a private equity firm to "wring out" inefficiencies before selling it off completely.

Other possibilities include an outright sale or contracting long-term leases.

June 1, 2007

The Money Road / A lack of resources is causing states to look at privatization to fund transportation projects.

Source: By Matt Sundeen, State Legislatures (subscription required), May 2007

...... The monetization of transportation assets—commonly referred to as privatization agreements, public-private partnerships, or more simply as P3s—is attracting a lot of attention as lawmakers grapple with concerns about a lack of resources for transportation.

“It allowed us to pay for our entire 10-year transportation plan,” says Indiana Senator Tom Wyss about a 2006 agreement to privatize the Indiana Toll Road. “Other states wish they could have the same thing,” he says.

But the concept has as many critics as supporters. “It’s a state yard-sale,” counters New Jersey Assemblyman John Wisniewski of a proposal to privatize several toll roads in his state. “Roads are a state asset that give people freedom of movement and are essential to national security. They want to turn it over to a private entity that’s in it for the money, not the public interest,” says Wisniewski, who chairs the Assembly Transportation Committee.

Corporation offers tunnel deal / $60-million lease is worth considering, Cockrel says

Source: BY TAMARA AUDI, Detroit FREE PRESS (MI), June 1, 2007


The president of Detroit's City Council said Thursday the city would have to "give serious consideration" to a surprise, $60-million bid from a private equity firm to lease the U.S. portion of the Detroit-Windsor Tunnel. The bid came weeks after Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick publicly outlined a plan to plug the city's yawning budget gap by leasing the tunnel to the City of Windsor for an up-front payment of $58 million after fees and expenses.

May 22, 2007

Turnpike lease looks good on paper

Source: By Tom Barnes, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (PA), Tuesday, May 22, 2007


Advisers to Gov. Ed Rendell say the state could rake in up to $18 billion by leasing the Pennsylvania Turnpike to a private operator for 30 years, which in turn could produce funding for fixing miles of roads and hundreds of bridges and even generate enough money to bail out mass transit agencies.

May 21, 2007

Move toward privatization has investors licking chops

Source: By Dale Kasler, Sacramento Bee (CA), Friday, May 18, 2007


If California tries to lease its state lottery to private investors or unload a state-owned student-loan business, as Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger proposes, there will likely be no shortage of interested parties. Providing capital to a growing privatization movement, investors are offering billions for state lotteries, toll roads and other government-owned assets nationwide.


May 14, 2007

Ex-Indianapolis mayor joins investment firm

Source: Indianapolis Star, May 14, 2007

Stephen Goldsmith, who championed privatization as mayor of Indianapolis for two terms in the 1990s, has joined an investment company with money to spend on government assets. Goldsmith will work for CapitalSource, a commercial lender and investment business in Chevy Chase, Md., as director of its new Infrastructure Finance and Investment Group, a news release said. ……. "The new group will focus on acquiring and financing long-life infrastructure assets -- transportation, utility or recreation -- across the United States," the company said.

April 30, 2007

Roads To Riches / Why investors are clamoring to take over America's highways, bridges, and airports—and why the public should be nervous

Source: By Emily Thornton, Business Week, MAY 7, 2007

……With state and local leaders scrambling for cash to solve short-term fiscal problems, the conditions are ripe for an unprecedented burst of buying and selling. All told, some $100 billion worth of public property could change hands in the next two years, up from less than $7 billion over the past two years; a lease for the Pennsylvania Turnpike could go for more than $30 billion all by itself. "There's a lot of value trapped in these assets," says Mark Florian, head of North American infrastructure banking at Goldman, Sachs & Co (GS ).

There are some advantages to private control of roads, utilities, lotteries, parking garages, water systems, airports, and other properties. To pay for upkeep, private firms can raise rates at the tollbooth without fear of being penalized in the voting booth. Privateers are also freer to experiment with ideas like peak pricing, a market-based approach to relieving traffic jams. And governments are making use of the cash they're pulling in—balancing budgets, retiring debt, investing in social programs, and on and on. But are investors getting an even better deal? It's a question with major policy implications as governments relinquish control of major public assets for years to come.

January 25, 2007

Illinois Is Putting Lottery on Block for Quick Payoff

Source: By CHARLES DUHIGG and JENNY ANDERSON, New York Times, January 23, 2007

The state of Illinois yesterday took the first steps in selling its state lottery system, hoping to attract as much as $10 billion from investors who, in return, would own a monopoly that could turn out to be the biggest jackpot yet. The sale, which may occur as early as the spring, would not be the first privatization of public property — both Chicago and Indiana have recently earned billions of dollars by signing long-term leases with private companies to run toll roads. But the proposed lottery sale is almost certain be one of the largest privatizations of a state-run program, and it raises concerns that states, some of them critically short of cash, are selling valuable assets that could otherwise provide consistent streams of revenue.

January 8, 2007

The Highwaymen / Why you could soon be paying Wall Street investors, Australian bankers, and Spanish builders for the privilege of driving on American roads.

Source: by Daniel Schulman with James Ridgeway, Mother Jones, January/February 2007 Issue

........ Fifty years to the day after Ike put his pen to the Highway Act, another Republican signed off on another historic highway project. On June 29, 2006, Mitch Daniels, the former Bush administration official turned governor of Indiana, was greeted with a round of applause as he stepped into a conference room packed with reporters and state lawmakers. The last of eight wire transfers had landed in the state's account, making it official: Indiana had received $3.8 billion from a foreign consortium made up of the Spanish construction firm Cintra and the Macquarie Infrastructure Group (mig) of Australia, and in exchange the state would hand over operation of the 157-mile Indiana Toll Road for the next 75 years. ....... The one thing everyone agreed on was that the Indiana deal was just a prelude to a host of such efforts to come. Across the nation, there is now talk of privatizing everything from the New York Thruway to the Ohio, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey turnpikes, as well as of inviting the private sector to build and operate highways and bridges from Alabama to Alaska. More than 20 states have enacted legislation allowing public-private partnerships, or P3s, to run highways. Robert Poole, the founder of the libertarian Reason Foundation and a longtime privatization advocate, estimates that some $25 billion in public-private highway deals are in the works; a remarkable figure given that as of 1991, the total cost of the interstate highway system was estimated at $128.9 billion.

December 6, 2006

Pa. to solicit interest from private firms to privatize turnpike

Source: DEBORAH YAO, Associated Press (PA), Wed, Dec. 06, 2006


The state will solicit "expressions of interest" from private firms to lease or take over the Pennsylvania Turnpike to gauge how much revenue it would raise, Gov. Ed Rendell said Wednesday. Rendell said the money raised would go toward the state's highways and mass transit systems, parts of which are in dire need of repair.

December 5, 2006

Easton's water lease may not add much cash

Source: By Tracy Jordan, The Morning Call (PA), December 5, 2006

Easton Mayor Phil Mitman has promoted the lease of the city's water system as a way to generate a minimum $2million in annual revenues and eliminate the need to borrow $20 million for a water plant upgrade. But a closer look at the arrangement with Easton Suburban Water Authority whittles down those numbers significantly. …….. Skeptics of the plan, mostly city employees who don't want to see the labor union downsized, criticize the lease agreement as an easy solution to balance the budget and question whether the city has considered all the consequences. ''It's like the city is pushing this through without looking at other alternatives,'' said Missy Corrado, president of American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Local 447. ''We don't believe that the city will receive all that money they are talking about.''

October 16, 2006

Alderman urges privatization of city’s water facilities

Source: MidHudsonNews.com (NY), Oct 14-15, 2006


Middletown – As the city works through the early stages of building a new water treatment plant at a cost of roughly $15 million, one alderman Friday called for the city to sell all of its water assets.

Alderman Raymond DePew said Middletown could make hundreds of millions of dollars if it sold everything – its reservoirs, water treatment plant, pipes – to a private company to operate.

August 8, 2006

Privatization hasn't been a faucet of money for Easton

Source: Michael P. Fleck, Morning Call (PA), August 7, 2006

"Privatization has not worked for Easton. Privatization has not worked for most municipalities in Pennsylvania.''

There is an old expression, ''If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.'' Currently, Easton is considering a 25-year lease of the city-owned water plant to Easton Suburban Water Authority. On the surface this looks like a great idea. The city gets a short term cash infusion, residents save on rates, and a private water expert is running the plant. But, doesn't this sound all too familiar?

It was a little over a decade ago that Easton residents were told how great private garbage collection was going to be. The city would receive a cash infusion, the residents would save money, and a private hauler would do a much better job. City leaders, at that time, sold off trucks and spent the proceeds. Now, that we do not have any trucks and the collection company has us over the barrel, or in this case over the dump truck, rates could go up as much as 300 percent. This is one example of city privatization gone poorly.


July 21, 2006

Public infrastructure shouldn't go private

Source: Tri City Herald (WA), Thursday, July 20th, 2006

Selling assets to solve a cash-flow problem might bring temporary relief, but it's no way to run a business. It's an even worse way to run a country. …… While some experts believe privatizing roads and bridges is a good way to give a budget boost to the government, something seems instinctively wrong with the practice. It isn't right, or fair, for Americans to pay tolls to foreign companies for the use of roads and bridges they've already paid for with taxes. ….. Someone ought to set out the flares and slow down this scary practice before it zooms out of control.

June 23, 2006

Harris County won't sell or lease toll roads

Source: By BILL MURPHY, Houston Chronicle (TX), June 21, 2006, 9:20AM

Rejecting the temptation of a multibillion-dollar windfall, the Harris County Commissioners Court voted unanimously Tuesday to continue running the county's lucrative toll road system rather than selling or leasing it to a private firm. "Now we can erect a sign on the toll roads: 'Not for sale, not for lease,' " said Commissioner Steve Radack, who had agreed to studying privatization even though he opposed the concept.

June 19, 2006

Privatizing I-69 may be uphill road

Source: By Theodore Kim, Indianapolis Star (IN), June 19, 2006

Tom Tokarski never thought Gov. Mitch Daniels' plan to lease out the Indiana Toll Road to a private, foreign consortium was a good idea. But, in that case, the Toll Road was already built. Tokarski views the controversial proposal to extend I-69 from Indianapolis to Evansville differently -- and as a much easier target for foes. Construction of the $2 billion highway link hasn't begun. And to privatize it, as is the plan, the governor must navigate a minefield of well-established opposition that has accumulated over decades.

June 15, 2006

Strapped States Try New Route, Lease Toll Roads to Foreign Firms

Source: By Amy Goldstein, Washington Post, Wednesday, June 14, 2006


……. The decision to hand the Indiana Toll Road to an Australian and Spanish team for $3.8 billion at the end of this month has blown up into one of the biggest brawls here in a generation. It has unsettled the state's politics in the months before the November elections, pitting a governor who was President Bush's first budget director against the people of northern Indiana, which the highway passes through. The decision also places Indiana at the leading edge of a nascent trend in which states and local governments are exploring the idea of privatizing parts of the United States' prized interstate highway system.

June 6, 2006

State hires consultant to study tollway leasing

Source: BY MONIFA THOMAS, Chicago Sun Times (IL), June 1, 2006

A state proposal to lease all or part of the Illinois tollway system to a private vendor gained momentum Wednesday with the award of a $30,000 contract to a consulting firm charged with determining just how much the state of Illinois might fetch for its toll roads. The consulting firm, Credit Suisse, will take about six weeks to complete its study. In the meantime, a state Senate budget committee began to hash out some of the particulars of tollway privatization Wednesday at the first of four public hearings.

April 19, 2006

Making Public Highways Private More State, Local Governments Consider Handing Toll Roads To Companies to Aid Budgets

Source: By LAURA MECKLER, Wall Street Journal, April 18, 2006

With federal, state and local governments facing budget squeezes, an increasing number of policy makers throughout the country are looking to privatize highways, encouraged by Wall Street companies seeking lucrative fees in the deals. The first big move came slightly more than a year ago, when a private partnership paid $1.83 billion for the right to operate the 7.8-mile Chicago Skyway for 99 years. Since then, Indiana has leased its 157-mile turnpike for 75 years for $3.8 billion. Other states, including New York, New Jersey and Delaware, have considered privatizing toll roads but haven't done so. …. Some analysts say the shift toward private ownership of what largely has been a public infrastructure has huge risks for the quality of the nation's roads. An analysis published last month by Fitch Ratings, a credit-ratings company, concluded that "toll roads are good candidates for privatization," but cautioned that adding a profit motive to the operation of roads could lead to tolls that are so high that drivers migrate to free highways, increasing pressure on those roads. It added that use of profits to fill a budget gap or other operational needs could lead to deficits down the line. "Ultimately, this is a one-time resource," it concludes.

April 13, 2006

Toll Road lease signed, promptly snared in lawsuits

Source: By Bill Ruthhart, Indianapolis Star (IN), April 13, 2006

As the ink was drying on a $3.8 billion agreement to lease the Indiana Toll Road, two lawsuits were filed Wednesday to block the deal. State Budget Director Charles Schalliol signed the 75-year lease agreement with Macquarie-Cintra, an Australian-Spanish consortium, at 9 a.m. Less than two hours later, lawsuits were filed in St. Joseph and Brown counties. A group of seven citizens and the Indianapolis-based Citizens Action Coalition of Indiana filed the St. Joseph County lawsuit, arguing that Gov. Mitch Daniels' effort to lease the Toll Road to a private firm was unconstitutional.

March 23, 2006