Job Evaluation Revisited: The Point Factor Method

Source: John G. Kilgour, Compensation & Benefits Review, Vol. 40 no. 4, 2008
(subscription required)

The point factor method of job evaluation consists of a large number of discretionary decisions that result in something that appears to be entirely objective and, even, scientific.

This article examines the oldest and most commonly used formal approach to job evaluation, the point factor method. It focuses on how and why things are done, with particular attention to the extent to which discretionary decisions are inherent in the process. Other approaches to formal job evaluation (the Hay guide-chart profile method, factor comparison, ranking and classification) are not addressed. However, much of the following discussion pertains to them as well.

Leave a Reply